Audiobook Sample

Listen to the sample to experience the story.

Please wait while we verify your browser...

  • Title: If You Tell: A True Story of Murder, Family Secrets, and the Unbreakable Bond of Sisterhood
  • Author: Gregg Olsen
  • Narrator: Karen Peakes
  • Length: 10:34:53
  • Version: Abridged
  • Release Date: 01/12/2019
  • Publisher: Brilliance Audio
  • Genre: True Crime, Mystery, Thriller & Horror
  • ISBN13: 9.78E+12
Hey digital truth-seekers and story obsessives,

Let’s break this down: Karen Peakes’ narration of Gregg Olsen’s “If You Tell” isn’t just an audiobook – it’s an emotional excavation. As someone who’s analyzed hundreds of audio narratives for my ‘Future of Stories’ podcast, I can tell you this production redefines what true crime can achieve through sound. The cultural impact here is profound – it’s the audio equivalent of that moment in a horror film when the lights go out and your other senses heighten.

Remember when we all collectively gasped at “The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo”‘s narrator choices? Peakes operates on that same razor’s edge of vocal precision, but with higher stakes. Her ability to toggle between Shelly Knotek’s terrifying manipulations and her daughters’ fragile resilience creates an almost physical tension. I found myself pausing the audio during particularly brutal sections – not because of the content alone, but because Peakes’ delivery made me need breathing room.

The genius of this audiobook lies in its paradoxes. Olsen’s journalistic rigor (those meticulously reconstructed scenes!) meets Peakes’ emotional intelligence in ways that print can’t replicate. When Sami describes her mother’s ‘love’ that felt like barbed wire, Peakes doesn’t just read those words – she makes you feel the hooks. As a digital storyteller, I’m obsessed with how this production uses silence as weaponry; those half-beat pauses before each new horror land like body blows.

Here’s what makes this interesting for us format nerds: True crime often struggles in audio because visual evidence (crime scene photos, documents) can’t be presented. But Olsen and Peakes turn this limitation into strength. The sisters’ whispered conversations in their shared bedroom? You hear every shaky breath between them. The creak of floorboards signaling Shelly’s approach? More terrifying than any jump scare. It’s ASMR from hell, and it works.

Compared to other true crime audiobooks I’ve analyzed (“I’ll Be Gone in the Dark” comes closest), “If You Tell” stands apart in its psychological depth. Where some narrators play true crime like a detached detective, Peakes makes you complicit – you’re not just learning what happened, you’re surviving it alongside Nikki, Sami and Tori. That time I compared five versions of “Project Hail Mary”? This deserves the same treatment for how audio transforms trauma narratives.

For my fellow digital anthropologists: Note how the sisters’ bond translates aurally. Peakes gives each sister distinct vocal fingerprints that gradually synchronize as their solidarity strengthens. It’s a masterclass in using voice as character development – when they finally unite against Shelly, their voices literally harmonize in ways that print can’t convey.

The only critique? This isn’t casual listening. You’ll need recovery time between chapters. But that’s the point – great audio doesn’t entertain, it transforms. And “If You Tell” might just change how you hear the world.

Stay curious (and maybe keep the lights on), Sophie
Sophie Bennett