Audiobook Sample

Listen to the sample to experience the story.

Please wait while we verify your browser...

  • Title: One of Us Is Lying
  • Author: Karen M. McManus
  • Narrator: Kim Mai Guest, MacLeod Andrews, Robbie Daymond, Shannon McManus
  • Length: 0.447222222
  • Version: Abridged
  • Release Date: 30-May
  • Publisher: Listening Library (Audio)
  • Genre: Teen, Mystery & Thriller, Tough Topics, Teen, Mystery & Thriller, Tough Topics, Teen, Mystery & Thriller, Tough Topics, Teen, Mystery & Thriller, Tough Topics
  • ISBN13: 9.78E+12
Hey listeners and literary detectives,

Let’s talk about Karen M. McManus’s ‘One of Us Is Lying’ audiobook—a teen mystery thriller that’s been described as ‘Pretty Little Liars meets The Breakfast Club,’ but I’d argue it’s more than just a mash-up of tropes. It’s a layered exploration of secrets, identity, and the lengths we’ll go to protect our truths—all wrapped in the intrigue of a murder mystery. Narrated by an ensemble cast including Kim Mai Guest, MacLeod Andrews, Robbie Daymond, and Shannon McManus, this audiobook elevates the storytelling to an immersive, multi-dimensional experience. Here’s what makes this interesting…

**Initial Impressions and Personal Connection:**
Listening to ‘One of Us Is Lying’ brought me back to my days as a curious teenager, where the cafeteria was a stage and every conversation felt like its own drama. The book’s premise—a detention gone awry, leaving one student dead and four suspects—is instantly gripping. It reminded me of my podcast episode on ‘Project Hail Mary,’ where the audiobook’s sound design added depth to the alien language. Similarly, the narrators here use their voices like instruments, creating distinct character profiles that feel alive. For example, Kim Mai Guest’s Bronwyn is intelligent and deliberate, while Robbie Daymond’s Nate is effortlessly rebellious and layered with vulnerability. Their performances made me feel like I was eavesdropping on real conversations, not just listening to a book.

**Narrator Performance and Audio Quality:**
The ensemble cast is a standout feature. Each narrator does justice to their character’s personality—Kim Mai Guest captures Bronwyn’s brainy confidence, Shannon McManus brings Addy’s evolving complexity to life, MacLeod Andrews nails Cooper’s stoic athleticism, and Robbie Daymond delivers Nate’s edgy charm with just the right amount of grit. The interplay between these voices feels natural, and the audio production is crisp, with subtle effects like pauses and intonations that heighten suspense. It’s clear that the narrators didn’t just read the book; they embodied it, adding layers of emotion and nuance that a text-based experience might not fully convey.

**Themes and Cultural Impact:**
Thematically, ‘One of Us Is Lying’ dives into tough topics like bullying, social media’s influence, and the pressure to conform to stereotypes—a timely reflection of teen life in the digital age. As someone deeply entrenched in analyzing digital storytelling and social media culture, I found Simon’s character—the creator of Bayview High’s gossip app—especially compelling. He’s the dark side of online influence, showing how secrets can be weaponized in the quest for power. This aspect of the story resonated with me and reminded me of my BookTok series on ‘The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo,’ where listeners explored how narrators could bring out hidden layers of character complexity.

**Strengths and Limitations:**
The audiobook’s greatest strength is its ability to immerse you in the mystery and keep you guessing. The narrators’ performances feel authentic, and the pacing is spot-on, making it hard to hit pause. However, the story does lean into some familiar tropes, particularly with its high-school archetypes—the brain, the beauty, the criminal, and the athlete. While McManus cleverly subverts these stereotypes as the story unfolds, some listeners might find the setup predictable. Also, the multiple narrators, while effective, occasionally create tonal shifts that may feel jarring depending on your listening preferences.

**Comparison with Similar Works:**
If you enjoyed the layered mystery of books like ‘A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder’ or the ensemble drama of ‘We Were Liars,’ this audiobook is undoubtedly for you. However, its closest cousin might be ‘Pretty Little Liars,’ though I’d argue ‘One of Us Is Lying’ offers a more satisfying resolution and a deeper exploration of character motivations.

**Recommendations for Potential Listeners:**
This audiobook is perfect for fans of teen dramas, mystery thrillers, and character-driven stories. Whether you’re a seasoned audiobook listener or new to the format, the ensemble cast and dynamic storytelling make this a great entry point. I’d especially recommend it for anyone navigating the complexities of high school life (or looking to revisit those days with a more suspenseful twist).

**Personal Reflection:**
As someone who’s spent years analyzing the intersection of digital culture and storytelling, I was particularly struck by how ‘One of Us Is Lying’ captures the essence of modern teenhood—the constant navigation of identity and the ever-present specter of social media. This audiobook reminded me why I love this format: it turns a story into an experience, allowing you to hear the characters’ emotions and feel the tension in their silences. It’s a testament to how audiobooks can transform the way we connect with a narrative.

**Closing:**
Whether you’re here for the mystery, the drama, or the stellar audiobook performances, ‘One of Us Is Lying’ offers an experience worth diving into. Happy listening, and as always, let me know what you think—I love hearing your audiobook reflections!

Yours in literary exploration,
Sophie Bennett

Warmest regards,